Freedom & Necessity, by Steven Brust and Emma Bull. Orb, 1997 I thought this book was a fantasy when I picked it up. I’m not familiar with Brust, but I’ve read Bull’s ‘War for the Oaks’ and it was certainly fantasy. Also, the excerpted line on the back of the book says “Have with you, at all times, iron that cuts, polished silver, a sprig of mistletoe, and a loaded pistol”. That sounds like magic. The cover also mentions occult societies and a protagonist who comes to his senses with two months missing from his memory and finds that he is presumed drowned.
It turns out that the book is historical fiction, set in 1849 England. There is an occult society, but they work no magic. Many plots abound, however- it takes the protagonists a very long time to get them all sorted out. A really long time- the book unfolds very, very slowly. It’s told via a series of letters from various protagonists to each other and by journal entries. This makes it seem to move even slower- the element of immediacy is missing by using this method of telling. It *does* give it the feeling of a Victorian novel.
The protagonists are generally likable, the setting is well detailed, and the plot makes sense. But, as I’ve said, it’s a very slow book and it wasn’t what I expected from the cover.